A think-aloud study exploring the application of composite time trade-off and discrete choice experiment methods for valuing the Chinese Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (C-SWEMWBS).
Hei Hang Edmund Yiu, Ling Hin Chow, Cheri Cheuk Lam Au, Eunice Kehui Deng, Zimeng Zhao, Yue Wei, Kyung Jin Lee, Caige Huang, Yu Yang, Wei Kang, Stavros Petrou, Jason Madan, Esther W Chan
Abstract
Open AccessBACKGROUND: To investigate the cognitive experiences of completing composite time trade-off (C-TTO) and discrete choice experiment (DCE) tasks for the valuation of the Chinese Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (C-SWEMWBS) in Hong Kong in order to inform an appropriate preference elicitation protocol for this population. METHODS: Eighteen think-aloud interviews employing concurrent and retrospective think-aloud techniques were conducted with Cantonese-speaking adult members of the general population. Each participant completed five C-TTO and five DCE tasks with tailor-made C-SWEMWBS states. Interview transcripts were transcribed verbatim, translated into English, and analysed thematically to identify patterns in participants' thoughts and understanding during task completion. RESULTS: Participants generally found the C-TTO and DCE tasks manageable. Four themes were identified that reflected participants' experiences: (1) Interview design and structure, bringing attention to potential refinements in presentation and instructions; (2) Representation of items and levels, illustrating participants' comprehension of the different C-SWEMWBS items and levels; (3) Influences on decision-making, identifying personal and external factors that shaped participant's decisions; and (4) Appropriateness of measures, reflecting participant's experiences in imagining and deriving utility values for mental well-being states. CONCLUSION: Despite highlighting areas that could be refined to minimise unnecessary cognitive burden, findings indicate that the design of the C-TTO and DCE tasks is both feasible and appropriate for the preference elicitation of C-SWEMWBS states in Hong Kong. This provides the basis for conducting a large-scale study to derive a preference-based value set for the C-SWEMWBS in Hong Kong for economic evaluations of interventions aimed at improving public mental well-being.